Why curiosity, reflection and not always having the answers are an important part of developing as a counsellor.
I wonder how many counsellors have found themselves approaching a supervision session thinking, "I haven't really got anything to bring today", particularly when their client work seems to be going well and there haven't been any particular challenges or concerns that they feel they need to discuss.
It's something I've come across quite often in my work as a clinical supervisor and it always makes me a little curious. While there may genuinely be nothing pressing that needs our attention, I do wonder whether we sometimes fall into the habit of thinking that supervision is somewhere we go when something has gone wrong, we're feeling stuck or we need someone to help us work out what to do next. Of course those are all important reasons to bring something to supervision, but I think there's so much more we can explore when we allow ourselves to be curious about our work, our experiences and perhaps most importantly, ourselves as practitioners.
Does Something Have to Be Wrong for Supervision to Be Useful?
One of the things I've noticed over the years is that a supervisee might arrive at a session feeling that they haven't really got much to discuss. But as we begin talking, whether that's about their client work or simply how things have been going for them personally, something often emerges that neither of us had necessarily anticipated. I think it's important to remember that supervisees have lives outside their counselling work too. Sometimes what's happening in those lives can influence how they're feeling, how much emotional capacity they have or even how they're experiencing their relationships with clients.
I often find that simply checking in with someone and being interested in how they're doing can open up conversations that are just as valuable as discussing a particular client. We don't suddenly become separate from our own experiences and emotions when we step into our role as counsellors.
Of course part of our professional responsibility is developing an awareness of what belongs to us and what belongs to our clients and learning how to manage those boundaries. We might become quite good at compartmentalising things, recognising that something is happening in our personal lives but being able to put it to one side while we're working.
Or perhaps we've finished a particularly emotional client session and moved on to the next part of our day, believing we've managed to leave that experience behind. But I do wonder whether sometimes, even when we think we've put something aside mentally, we're still carrying some of its emotional impact without necessarily recognising it. Perhaps we notice we're feeling unusually tired, tense or unsettled, or that our body seems to be holding on to something that we haven't quite processed. And then of course there are those times when a client suddenly pops into our thoughts at two in the morning. We find ourselves wondering how they're doing, worrying about something they've shared or questioning whether we could have done something differently.
I suspect quite a few counsellors will recognise that experience.
For me this is another reason why it's important to make room in supervision to talk about how we're doing rather than focusing exclusively on the work we're doing. It's not about turning supervision into personal therapy, but recognising that our wellbeing, our experiences and the emotional demands of our work are all worth paying attention to, particularly when we might be carrying more than we realise. Sometimes it might be a particular interaction with a client, something they've noticed about themselves, a change within the therapeutic relationship or even a session that went particularly well. Before we know it we've found ourselves exploring something that perhaps hadn't seemed especially significant at first.
I don't think we always need to go looking for a problem where there isn't one and I certainly wouldn't want a supervisee to feel they need to manufacture something simply because they have a supervision appointment. Sometimes things really are going well and that's worth recognising too.But I think there can still be value in exploring what's contributing to that, what we're learning and how our understanding of ourselves as counsellors might be developing. For me this is where curiosity becomes such an important part of supervision, because sometimes it's the conversations we hadn't planned to have that lead to some of the most meaningful reflections.
Being Curious Rather Than Having All the Answers
Curiosity is something I often talk about with my supervisees and I think it's one of the most valuable things we can bring into our therapeutic work. It encourages us to look beyond what's immediately in front of us and consider what else might be happening.
Sometimes when a supervisee is talking about a client I might notice a response in myself, perhaps feeling angry on behalf of the client or wondering why a particular situation has affected me in a certain way. Rather than dismissing that response I might share it and become curious about what's happening for the supervisee. Are they experiencing something similar or is their response completely different? What might that tell us about how we're understanding the client's experience or perhaps something happening within the therapeutic relationship?
I think there's something valuable about being able to explore these things together rather than assuming that as the supervisor I should automatically know the answer. Although I have experience and training to draw upon, I certainly don't consider myself a font of all knowledge and there will always be things I haven't encountered before or areas where I need to develop my own understanding.
If I don't know something I'm quite happy to acknowledge that and go away and find out. I don't believe that learning stops when we qualify or when we become supervisors and actually I think there's something important about being able to model that openness with our supervisees too.
Sometimes I think of supervision as trying to make sense of a puzzle where we bring our different experiences, knowledge and perspectives together and explore how the pieces might fit. We might not always have every piece or arrive at a definite answer and I think that's something we have to become comfortable with.
I remember something one of my lecturers said when I was training which has stayed with me ever since, that as counsellors we manage uncertainty all the time. The more I've worked with clients and supervisees the more I've come to appreciate just how true that is. We don't always know what a client is going to bring into the room, how a therapeutic relationship might develop or whether something we're exploring will lead to the understanding we're hoping for. At the same time we're managing our own lives, experiences and emotions which don't simply disappear because we're sitting in the counsellor's chair.
I remember that feeling of uncertainty particularly during COVID when the way we worked as counsellors changed almost overnight. For many of us face-to-face sessions were no longer possible and we had to adapt to working remotely, finding different ways of connecting with clients while navigating the practical and emotional challenges that came with it. There was a real need for flexibility, not only in how we worked but in how we responded to a situation that none of us had experienced before. And while we were supporting clients through their fears, isolation, losses and uncertainty we were also living through those same circumstances ourselves, managing our own anxieties and worrying about the people we cared about.
I think that experience really brought home how counselling doesn't take place in isolation from the rest of our lives.
The same can be true when we're experiencing something like grief. We might be dealing with the loss of someone important to us, trying to make sense of our own feelings and somehow continuing to work with clients who may also be experiencing loss, sadness or difficult emotions. We can remain professional and present for our clients while recognising that we're human too and that sometimes our own experiences may affect us in ways we haven't fully appreciated.
As a supervisor this is something I pay particular attention to when exploring a supervisee's caseload. I think it's important to consider not only the number of clients they're working with but also the emotional demands of that work and what else might be happening in their lives. Someone might be managing their client work well from a clinical perspective but that doesn't necessarily tell us how much they're carrying personally or whether they're allowing themselves enough space to process their own experiences.
I think part of my role is to be curious about that with them, exploring whether their caseload feels manageable, how they're looking after themselves and whether there might be anything they could do differently to reduce the risk of burnout.It's not simply about encouraging self-care, it's about helping supervisees recognise their own emotional capacity and understand that this can change depending on what's happening in their lives. Sometimes being able to acknowledge that we haven't got the same capacity we had a few months ago is an important part of maintaining both our wellbeing and our ability to practise safely and effectively.
I think there's something important about recognising that we're often holding both our clients' experiences and our own while trying to remain present, thoughtful and aware of what might be happening within the therapeutic relationship. We can become quite skilled at managing uncertainty but that doesn't mean we always recognise its impact on us or that we should expect ourselves to manage everything without support.
And perhaps that's another reason why supervision matters, because it gives us somewhere to explore those uncertainties rather than feeling we always need to resolve them on our own.
Can I Bring Something to Supervision If I Think I've Got It Wrong?
I think this is particularly important for student counsellors and those who are newly qualified because there can sometimes be a worry about how we might be perceived if we admit that we're struggling, feeling unsure or perhaps haven't handled something in the way we'd hoped.
Supervision is of course an important part of maintaining ethical and safe practice and as a clinical supervisor I have a responsibility to recognise and address concerns when they arise. But I don't believe that this needs to come at the expense of creating a supportive and non-judgemental relationship.
I'd much rather someone felt comfortable enough to tell me that something hadn't gone well than sit through a supervision session feeling they needed to convince me that everything was fine. I think it's often in those moments of uncertainty or discomfort that we can learn something really valuable about ourselves and our work. For me it's about being able to explore what happened, what they were thinking or feeling at the time, what they might understand differently now and whether there's anything we need to consider moving forward.
That might involve reflecting on an ethical concern, exploring a different approach or recognising an area where further learning or CPD could be helpful, but it doesn't have to mean that someone has failed.
I also think it's important that supervisees feel able to question or disagree with me because I don't want them to simply adopt my way of thinking or working. I want them to develop their own clinical judgement, feel confident in exploring different perspectives and recognise that their own experiences and understanding have value too.
The Counsellor Is Part of the Therapeutic Process Too
Something else I think is worth remembering is that we often spend so much time focusing on our clients and their experiences that we can overlook what's happening for us as practitioners. I've always felt that the therapist is an important part of the therapeutic process and that means recognising that we bring our own experiences, beliefs, emotions and sometimes the things happening in our personal lives into the work we do.
Sometimes we might notice ourselves feeling frustrated with a client, particularly when we can see them struggling or making decisions that we feel might be unhelpful. While that frustration can sometimes come from a place of care or wanting to rescue them, it can also be worth exploring whether there's something else happening for us. Perhaps the client's experience reminds us of something we've been through ourselves or we're experiencing an emotional response that we haven't quite been able to make sense of yet.
I think this is where the difference between processing something internally and having the opportunity to externalise those thoughts and feelings in supervision can be so valuable. Sometimes we're not fully aware of what's happening for us until we begin talking about it with someone else. We might recognise an emotion without really understanding where it's coming from or notice a pattern in our work without having joined the dots about what might be influencing it.
I remember working with two young clients who were on my caseload at the same time... Both around sixteen years old, who had very similar presenting difficulties. Generally I've always felt quite comfortable with therapeutic endings and recognise their importance but with these particular clients I noticed that I kept extending our work together. I started to question why I was finding it so difficult to bring the relationships to an end. I enjoyed working with them and genuinely cared about their wellbeing but I also had a sense that there was something more happening for me that I hadn't quite understood. As I began reflecting on this I recognised that aspects of their experiences reminded me of my own difficulties at a similar age, particularly the feeling that nobody had really noticed what I was going through or offered the support I needed at the time.
What I eventually realised was that part of me wanted to make sure I was there for these young people in a way that I felt nobody had been there for me. Although that came from a place of care it was also important to recognise how my own experiences might have been influencing my clinical decisions. For me this was a valuable reminder of how countertransference can sometimes show itself in ways that aren't immediately obvious and why continuing to develop our self-awareness is such an important part of therapeutic practice. It wasn't simply about recognising that I cared about these clients but understanding what was happening for me within those relationships and being able to consider their needs separately from my own experiences.
It's also interesting how good we can be at encouraging our clients to take time for themselves, recognise when they're feeling overwhelmed or make space for their own needs while sometimes finding it much harder to follow that same advice ourselves.
I think supervision offers an opportunity to check in with the person behind the counsellor too, whether that's exploring how they're managing their workload, recognising the emotional impact of their client work or simply considering whether they're allowing themselves enough time to decompress.
Because while developing our knowledge and skills is important, so is developing our self-awareness and understanding of how we experience the work we do.
Supervision Is Also About Recognising Your Growth
I really enjoy seeing supervisees develop over time, particularly when they begin to recognise their own strengths, feel more confident in their clinical judgement and become increasingly comfortable reflecting on their work without feeling they need to have everything figured out. I think it's important that we make space for those moments too.
Supervision doesn't always need to be about exploring difficulties or identifying what we could have done differently because sometimes there's just as much to learn from understanding why something went well, what we brought to that interaction and how our skills or confidence might have developed.
For me professional development isn't simply about attending training courses or gaining more qualifications, although continuing professional development certainly has its place. It's also about becoming more aware of ourselves, remaining open to different perspectives and recognising that our understanding of both our clients and ourselves will continue to evolve throughout our careers.
So, What If You Really Don't Have Anything to Bring?
Well that's okay too...
You don't necessarily need to arrive at every clinical supervision session with a particular question, a difficult client situation or a list of things you want to discuss because sometimes it's through the conversation itself that we begin to notice something worth exploring. Sometimes there genuinely isn't anything particularly challenging happening which gives us an opportunity to reflect on what's going well, recognise our development or simply check in with how we're experiencing our work.
I suppose what I'd really like my supervisees to take away from our sessions is a feeling that they've been heard and supported but also that they've had an opportunity to think, reflect and perhaps leave feeling a little inspired or curious about something they hadn't considered before.
Because for me good supervision isn't about having all the answers, it's about having a space where we feel comfortable enough to explore the questions
Add comment
Comments